Debate
Debate
Forensic Accounting, Valuations and E-Discovery
Forensic Accounting, Valuations and E-Discovery

Investigating and quantifying shareholder disputes – a forensic accountant’s perspective

In our latest insight, Gary Moore from our Disputes, Investigations & Valuations team, discusses the role forensic accountants play in resolving shareholder disputes and highlights the importance of early intervention to maintain business stability.

Contents

Back to Top

A large proportion of the cases our Disputes, Investigations and Valuations team deals with are shareholder disputes in one form or another. These are disputes between company owners for a variety of reasons including disagreements on decision-making, dividend distribution, access to information, business strategy, or perceived unfair treatment; often with a power imbalance between majority and minority shareholders. 

Disputes between shareholders (often owner managers) distract the management team from focusing on the success of the company and running the company. The fallout from shareholder disputes can be really detrimental to the success of the business. Resolving shareholder disputes early is therefore crucial to prevent business disruption, protect relationships, safeguard financial interests, and maintain company stability. Early resolution can allow owner managers to focus on running the company, preserves trust among shareholders, enables smoother decision-making, can limit reputational damage, and can avoid legal costs as far as possible. 

Types of shareholder disputes

While unfair prejudice claims are the most common form of shareholder dispute we are instructed in, these are not the only forms of disputes between owners of a company. An example of some recent cases that we’ve seen include the following:

  • Minority shareholder unfair prejudice claims – this is where a minority shareholder claims that actions taken by the majority shareholder are prejudicial to the interests of the minority shareholder
  • Deadlock disputes – Shareholders with equal control that cannot agree on key decisions, preventing the company from operating.
  • Financial and dividend disputes – Disagreements about profit distribution, salaries, or use of company funds.
  • Valuation and exit disputes – Conflicts over the fair value of shares during buyouts or exits. 

The role of a forensic accountant in shareholder disputes

The role of a forensic accountant in shareholder disputes is not just about putting a number on a claim. Forensic accountants often play a crucial role in resolving shareholder disputes by providing financial analysis and an objective assessment of financial matters, right through to giving evidence at court if necessary. Key roles undertaken by a forensic can include: 

  1. Investigating financial records – examining company accounts, transactions, and financial statements to identify discrepancies, fraud, or mismanagement
     
  2. Quantifying losses – calculating financial losses suffered by shareholders and/or the company due impact of misuse of funds, unfair practices, or business underperformance
     
  3. Valuing shares – determining the value of shares in the company, and often the value of a minority shareholder’s interest in the company with or without adjusting for the alleged financial wrongdoing
     
  4. Minority discounts – while the application of a minority discount is ultimately a decision for the court, we are often asked to give an opinion on the likely level of a minority discount based that may be appropriate should the court decide that it’s applicable 
     
  5. Tracing assets – identifying hidden, diverted, or misappropriated company assets that may be central to the dispute
     
  6. Providing expert testimony at court – giving evidence in court or arbitration as an expert witness, explaining complex financial matters clearly and impartially

By combining investigative skills, accounting knowledge, and valuation expertise forensic accountants provide a crucial role in understanding and quantifying the issues in play in shareholder disputes.  

Examples of some recent shareholder dispute cases 

1. Case One – Unfair prejudice petition (Industry: Financial Services)

The shareholders alleged that the managing director breached his fiduciary duties by using company funds for personal expenses and misappropriating company assets.

Forensic steps: securing accounting records, reviewing bank and credit-card transactions, testing expense claims, analysing asset registers, tracing asset movements, examining e-mails, conducting interviews with staff, reviewing board minutes and authority levels, and quantifying the value of misappropriated funds and assets.

Outcome: the investigation identified personal spending disguised as business costs and assets removed without authorisation, supporting the shareholders allegations.


2. Case Two – Minority shareholder unfair prejudice petition (Industry: Facilities Management)

A minority shareholder filed an unfair-prejudice claim alleging the majority shareholder extracted value from the business and acted in bad faith, reducing the company’s value and her shareholding.

Forensic steps: securing financial records, analysing bank transactions, reviewing related-party payments, examining board minutes and approvals, assessing management remuneration, performing journal-entry testing, conducting email reviews, interviewing key finance staff, and quantifying the financial impact.

Outcome: Findings showed undisclosed transactions, inflated management remuneration and exclusion from decision-making. Evidence supported the minority shareholder’s unfair-prejudice petition, quantifying financial loss and governance failures.

3. Case Three – Minority shareholder unfair prejudice petition (Industry: Manufacturing)

A minority shareholder alleged unfair prejudice after the majority shareholder diverted company funds into large sponsorship payments benefiting a rugby club he was personally involved with.

Forensic steps: securing accounting records, analysing sponsorship transactions, reviewing board approvals, tracing related-party links, examining e-mails, testing procurement processes, interviewing staff, and quantifying the financial impact on company value.

Outcome: Findings showed inadequate approvals, conflicts of interest, and excessive spending inconsistent with commercial benefit, supporting the minority shareholder’s claim.

Final thoughts 

Shareholder disputes can be damaging to a company, the resolution of them in a timely manner is important for the stakeholders of the business. Understanding the financial issues and the values of shares is a key part in the process and in resolving the issues. The role of the forensic accountant is crucial to assisting the parties and their legal advisors when dealing with shareholder disputes.

Sign up to our Newsletter

Error: Contact form not found.

Get in Touch News & Insights

Latest News & Insights


November 11, 2026

Successful sale secures future of established bakery business

The client & the situation An established bakery business faced increasing financial pressure following a very substantial bad debt and rental increases of more than 200% over a relatively short period. Although the business remained operational and management believed its position would improve in the coming months, growing liabilities and facing difficulties in meeting its … Continued

October 27, 2026

Introducing the new KR8 Advisory 

Today marks the beginning of a new chapter for KR8 Advisory.  KR8 and Quantuma’s restructuring and forensic accounting business have officially come together under one brand, bringing more than 300 people across 14 offices together as one KR8.  But today isn’t simply about bringing two businesses together.  It’s about creating a broader advisory business for … Continued

October 23, 2026

Quantuma appointed administrators to Romford pharmacy Clockhouse Pharmacy

Experts from business advisory firm Quantuma have been appointed joint administrators to Care Pharma (Romford) Ltd, trading as Clockhouse Pharmacy, a community pharmacy based in Romford. Rehan Ahmed and Gareth Peckett were appointed as joint administrators on 14th October 2026. The administration has secured the continuation of the pharmacy business, with 11 of the 12 … Continued

October 21, 2026

Quantuma appointed to swimwear brand Away That Day Limited

Experts from business advisory firm Quantuma have been appointed joint administrators to premium swimwear brand Away That Day Limited (In administration). Sam Gaunt and Terri Mulgrew were appointed as joint administrators on 9th October 2026 and completed a pre-packaged sale of certain assets. The women’s swimwear business, launched in 2018, started as a direct-to-consumer e-commerce … Continued

September 30, 2026

All Jobs saved with pre-pack sale of online marketplace Laced Europe

Experts from business advisory firm Quantuma have completed the sale of online retailer Laced Europe Ltd out of administration. This pre-pack sale protects all jobs and secures the future of the business. Quantuma’s Terri Mulgrew and Michael Kiely were appointed as joint administrators on 22 September 2026, following a marketing and planning period, to enable … Continued

July 30, 2026

Understanding altcoins and blockchain technology

In this article, Mike Fanshawe from our Forensic Accounting, Valuations and E-Discovery team discusses altcoins and blockchain technology and provides insight into how forensic investigators approach tracing cryptoassets during investigations. Altcoins: An Overview Altcoins, short for “alternative coins”, generally refer to cryptocurrencies other than Bitcoin. Since Bitcoin’s launch in 2009, thousands of digital assets have … Continued

July 23, 2026

Collateral Warranties: What’s the point, and why are funders skipping them?

There’s a pattern worth calling out: on smaller transactions, banks and funders increasingly treat collateral warranties as optional. They are often viewed as documents that can be waived, deprioritised, or quietly dropped to keep legal costs and timescales down. The assumption seems to be that a smaller deal carries smaller risk. It doesn’t. Smaller schemes … Continued

July 14, 2026

KR8 Advisory strengthens real estate restructuring platform with acquisition of Recoveries and Receivership team from Allsop

KR8 Advisory has acquired the Allsop LLP Recoveries and Receivership team, marking a significant milestone in the continued growth of its real estate restructuring division.  The transaction brings an established and highly regarded receivership team into KR8, enhancing the firm’s ability to support lenders across complex real estate situations. The acquisition includes both the team … Continued

July 2, 2026

From financial distress to legal clarity: when insolvency demands a forensic deep dive

Insolvency is rarely a singular event. It typically unfolds over months, sometimes years, of financial strain, operational pressures, and internal decision making that may or may not withstand scrutiny. While many companies simply succumb to commercial realities, others exhibit signs that financial distress may be intertwined with misconduct, mismanagement, or breaches of fiduciary duty. For … Continued

June 18, 2026

Counting the cost of Compulsory Purchase Orders

Compulsory Purchase Orders (CPOs) are utilised for large infrastructure and regeneration projects such as new transport links, road widening schemes, housing developments or public redevelopment initiatives. While these projects are designed to deliver wider public benefits, they can have a significant impact on businesses forced to relocate or, in some cases, cease trading altogether. This … Continued

Let’s talk

Whether you’re facing an immediate challenge, considering your options or simply want an informed perspective, an early conversation can make a difference.